For Americans who care about social justice and basic human dignity, silence is not an acceptable option in this moment. The recent events in which video captures the murders of Ahmaud Arbery and George Floyd and the endangering of Christian Cooper by a privileged white woman (Amy Cooper, no relation) who calls the police with a false claim of threat. As I watch protests give way to full out rioting including the spectacle of both fires and looting across the country, I ask myself which path is the most effective.
Speaking as a black woman in America, I know we need change. We demand it. We have been demanding it since slavery and Jim Crow. I understand that blacks aren’t the only ethnic group who need a more equitable system in this country. Our nation’s history has shown that skin color determines treatment. And in this particular moment, black people are once again the ones under attack from multiple sides.
Years of economic, environmental, and healthcare discrimination have left us particularly vulnerable to dying from COVID-19. The virus doesn’t see skin color, but seeks opportunities. The economic and social systems in place created the heath disparities in conditions like asthma, high blood pressure, and diabetes coupled with an overrepresentation in frontline essential work that leaves us particularly vulnerable. And the fact that it is more difficult for blacks to even be tested speaks volumes about who is valued and who is not in this nation.
It wasn’t enough that COVID-19 is ravaging our families, but once again we have unjustified murders and a justice system dragging its feet toward accountability and justice. We only know about the murders caught on video. My guess is that many more go unreported, particularly involving police, because the cameras are not rolling. And just how many are serving prison sentences or paying large fines because of police malfeasance?
How can any decent American stay silent? At the very least protests are called for. Protest in social media. Protest among friends. Protest from microphones. Protest in writing to newspapers and lawmakers. Protest in the streets, but while wearing masks and practicing social distancing.
But has the level of offense against black lives reached the level where rioting is called for? Perhaps. But this is not my preference because it is scary and riots have proven to be self-destructive rather than constructive. I get that there is a symbolic meaning behind burning down buildings. It is a symbolic call to destroy an entire system. Burn it down to the ground in order to start again is the meaning. There is meaning behind looting, too. The meaning is that the economic transactional system currently in place is unfair in which the rich always win and the poor always loose. So, looting is a way to reject the transaction. For some, they think its just an opportunity to get free stuff. But even that mentality itself is a byproduct of an unjust system.
At this moment in time, I side with both the protesters and the rioters. I worry because I don’t see the street protesters and rioters wearing masks or practicing any social distancing. In 2-3 weeks there will likely be a horrible price to pay in more COVID-19 illnesses and deaths. This sad reality makes me even more hopeful that our business leaders, educators, and political leaders really see, really hear, and really understand that the present system is unjust and cannot persist.
People like me are longing for the current system that is built on structural racism to collapse. Death, destruction, and chaos are in our future if these leaders do not act to change things quickly. If these leaders just look at the burning cars and buildings and the looters as irrational acts of violence, then they are missing the point and eventually the whole system will be burned down with them inside it.