There is a very nice woman in my crochet and knitting circle who immigrated from the Philippines as a young girl. The other day over lunch at the senior center, she mentioned how she was in favor of the current deportations because people need to come here the “right way” like she and her family did. Anyone who knows me, knows that that kind of comment triggers a not-so-patient response from me. And it did.
Without raising my voice, I responded that the immigration system we have today is broken and that the path to coming here the “right way” is inadequate to meet our economic needs because it is outdated, grossly under-staffed and underfunded and largely inaccessible to many who are eligible to immigrate here. I told her that 90% of the people ICE is detaining by force and without due process have no criminal record but are hard-working people who pay taxes and support local economies. They even pay into the social security system we all rely on. My final words had to do with the fact that there was a time when the U.S. welcomed Europeans to the U.S. simply because they boarded a boat and landed on Ellis Island. With those comments, I left the center because I could feel my ire rising and I didn’t want to burst into flames.
It is no surprise that this Administration is losing in the polls on immigration policy. Every day we see videos of ICE agents targeting brown people on our streets using violence and denying them their due process. These agents ignore the Constitution and are fueled by unbridled power and monetary incentives to go after helpless people. Decent people couple that brutality with the dire conditions we hear about in the for-profit detention camps where girls and women are being raped, food is nearly inedible, detainees are mocked, and sick people can’t access medical care. The fact that ICE is detaining people who are here legally, separating families, and deporting people who had been contributors to our society is abhorrent to anyone with a shred of decency and human empathy.
Those who proclaim to be Christians should know that there are at least 30 Bible verses in both the Old and New Testament that clearly tell us that God expects us to welcome the foreigner or stranger and to treat them well. For example, “You shall treat the stranger who sojourns with you as the native among you, and you shall love him as yourself.” (Leviticus 19:34). Or how about this one, “For I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me drink, I was a stranger and you welcomed me.” (Matthew 25:35) There is no room in the Christian values that so many MAGA supporters claim to hold for the way the Trump Administration is treating immigrants.
And it is only getting worse. Stephen Miller announced that he is going after the 24,000 unaccompanied minors still in the country. With the Supreme Court’s approval, Trump has rescinded the Temporary Protected Status of nearly 350,000 Haitians who have been working hard and contributing to the local, state, and federal economy by paying taxes and buying necessities. Losing their protected status means they lose their jobs and their legal immigration status. These are people have established homes, careers, families, and friendships here in the U.S. and that is being ripped away from them simply because they are black. These are the same people he falsely accused of eating the cats and dogs during his presidential debate. I recall when Trump publicly said that he wants white immigrants, not immigrants from “shit hole” countries. However, his racists statements were not enough to convince the Supreme Court that this Haitian removal policy was not based on race as the plaintiffs argued before the Court.
It’s not as though white people from European countries are clamoring to come here. In fact, the opposite is true. Not only do most of them hate Trump, but their standard of living includes healthcare, paid family leave, and basic human freedoms. But people in many other countries have good reason to flee their home countries but can no longer come here. This Administration has set the cap for refugees to only 7500, down from 125,000 the previous year. Is anyone surprised that essentially the only refugees being admitted are white South Africans whom Trump claims are escaping a fabricated and completely unfounded “white genocide” in South Africa. According to Refugee Council USA, all but three of the refugees admitted to the U.S. this year were white South Africans. The other three were from East Asia. I think the Statue of Liberty should be taken down and put into storage until we regain our sanity and humanity as a nation.
What is clear to anyone with economic sense is that this nation has always needed the labor, tax revenues, and the spending of immigrants. Farmers can’t find enough labor with over 1.2 million positions left vacant (Microsoft Co-pilot). As a result, food prices are up because farmers suffer crop losses and are planting less. Healthcare is also experiencing a shortage of labor because of our aging population and immigrants often fill those jobs. Ironically, the largest percentage of Haitian workers are employed in healthcare, including hospitals, nursing homes, and home healthcare. Average people, like me, are experiencing long waits to see health professionals these days while the wealthy turn to concierge medicine. It took me three weeks to get my first physical therapy appointment. And the construction industry is also facing a shortfall of about 500,000 workers (Microsoft co-pilot). This creates project delays for basic infrastructure projects and housing. Trump’s immigration policies along with his ill-conceived tariffs and stupid war in Iran are literally destroying our economy. By deporting working immigrants, we have cut the tax base that supports social security, Medicare, and Medicaid. It’s no surprise that the deficit is quickly growing despite all the DOGE cuts and historic cuts to food assistance programs.
Like other nations with low birth rates, we rely on immigrants to keep the economy growing, fill essential jobs, and to support our aging population. The few South Africans Trump is bringing in will not make up for the millions of people we are deporting and banning from entry. Additionally, the brain-drain of scientists and aspiring scientists to other countries is real. And the loss of international students who subsidize the cost of educating our domestic students, has dropped dramatically. Many of our professionals across industries began as international students and opted to build a life here in the states. Others arrived through the H1B visa process for professionals. Unfortunately, those doors under Trump are rapidly closing and we will lose both the intellectual and economic advantage they gave us.
Trump’s immigration policies are driven by racism, xenophobia, and the myth of white supremacy. We can clearly see through his Cabinet appointments that whiteness does not equal competence. Our country is suffering from the lack of expertise and experience among government officials along with an anti-intellectualism and corruption mindset being elevated to the highest ranks of government. We can see in real time how Trump’s policies are destroying our economy and hurting actual people.
Our best hope to repair the damage is to elect a new Congress this November and a new president in 2028 who will actually fix our broken immigration system through adequate funding and staffing and updated immigration laws that value hard work, merit, and protection of the displaced persons without regard to their race. Our diversity and welcoming immigration policies have been the special sauce that built this nation. Immigrants bring a wealth of knowledge, innovation, energy, and culture that make this country thrive and it is time to enact reasonable immigration laws that protect our borders while also honoring multicultural values that enrich us all.
