I’ve seen a lot of Instagram posts these days mocking young women describing themselves as traditional wives or “trad wives”. These pretty young women in their early twenties brag about their happy marriage to a domineering alpha man. Without life experience nor knowledge of previous female hardships, they forego higher education in favor of maximizing their physical attractiveness while highlighting a level of vulnerability and dependence that strokes the male ego. They promote scary levels submissiveness, relishing their role as “helper” while offering to have produce as many babies as possible and playing Susie Homemaker. They are outspoken in their belief that women should give up the right to vote in favor of allowing their husband to vote on their behalf. And of course, sex with their husband is non-negotiable as it is their duty. When they speak, I feel like I’m watching a character right out of the Hulu series, “The Testaments” (the sequel to the “Handmaid’s Tale”, also written by Margaret Atwood in 1985). I think these young women genuinely want to live a good life. However, I recognize that they are naive, short-sighted, and far too eager to encourage other young women to follow in their footsteps.
I’m pretty certain that Republican white male “Christian” nationalists are behind this trad wife movement to subjugate women by funding it and promoting it. Republican legislatures in red states refuse to pass laws banning child marriage. This president is soft on sex crimes against girls and women. Their abortion bans and the prosecution of women who have had miscarriages further highlight their nefarious agenda. Their move to suppress the vote of women through the SAVE ACT is clear evidence. Even the refusal of Pete Hegseth to promote women to higher military ranks is indicative of where this movement is heading. Fox News host, Jesse Watters, joked about military women and women at ports needing to “be careful” because “these guys are going to be wild animals, and you better watch out” because of the testosterone boosting policy Hegseth just put into place.
These young women are likely daughters socialized in conservative evangelical churches to believe that the God sanctioned role of women is to marry, have children, keep silence, and submit to their husbands. They are taught to view too much education as a threat and undesirable to men. Feminism and self-sufficiency among women are the deceptive work of the devil. I know these women and how they think because I personally rejected this line of thinking when I was a teenager, vowing that I would never marry if this was what awaited me. I knew then that nothing short of an equal partnership in marriage would work for my dignity as a creation of God. It’s as though these people are using author Margaret Atwood’s 1985 and 2019 fictional books at their actual guidebook.
I have to surmise that there must be a passive personality, a lack of confidence, a lack of self-awareness, a lack intelligence or just blind faith in the young women who accept this lifestyle. Admittedly, most of the trad wives I have known were not very smart. This could have been because of the church and parental expectations they experienced since birth. I know they were raised to view themselves as below men in authority and subject to them. However, any girl raised alongside boys (like I was) knows there is something inherently wrong with the notion that boys are more capable and that suppressing one’s gifts, one’s intellectual curiosity, foregoing one’s autonomy, and that leaving oneself completely dependent on the whims of males is unwise. Inside, these young women know, as I knew, that they aren’t inherently dumber or less talented or less capable than their male counterparts. But some of them are convinced that God’s just punishment for women is for them is to have children and to protect the fragile male ego. And so, they will pretend to be content. Like the girls in “The Testaments” and on social media, they just want to be “picked”. And when they are, they will keep silent to keep the peace. They will feign meekness and look pretty. They will panic and pray in private every time poor decisions are made by a husband who has no reason to respect their opinions. Until they can’t.
This kind of suppression and pretending doesn’t last and neither does their outward beauty. And none of this is without emotional consequence. Only the more intellectually challenged, naturally passive, or emotionally damaged women are cut out to be trad wives. Most women have egos, too. Like Eve, most women are intellectually curious. And constantly belittling oneself will take a toll on such women. Many will eventually find themselves increasingly unable to bite their tongues. And sometimes violence or infidelity from the man who was supposed to protect them will be the result.
The scenario I have repeatedly seen among women who choose to be trad wives is pretty predictable. The man can’t escape his vices. He’s a serial cheater. He gambles. He drinks too much. He is prone to violence. He can’t keep a job. He spends too much on toys. He is inconsiderate. He takes too many risks. Like the previous traditional wives before them, most of these young women will find themselves trapped in an unhappy marriage and without the means to escape. It’s too common for the husband to eventually leave the trad wife for a younger model. Or should their husband die prematurely, they are ill-equipped to survive on their own so they will struggle until they find a new man to care for them and their children, hoping he is good to them. I’ve also met a few former trad wives who broke free and got their education and became independent self-sufficient women who may or may not find true partnerships later in life.
It should be a huge red flag to young women that there aren’t a lot of older trad wives out there promoting this lifestyle. There is a reason for this, and I hope that more experienced women share the necessity of self-sufficiency and loving partnerships that preserves both egos as a more satisfying alternative. A bit more mentorship and candid conversations with our daughters, grand-daughters and nieces is needed to combat the promotion of female subjugation. Or a viewing of “The Handmaid’s Tale” and the “The Testaments” on Hulu might do the job.
